6 Influencer Engagement Tips from Shark Tank

Holding anyone’s attention–let alone a highly influential investor–is not for the faint of heart.

Whether it’s an investor or an influencer, there will come a time when you have only five minutes to make the most important pitch of your life. How you are perceived in those five minutes will make or break your career.

Watching other people experience those five minutes is exhilarating.

That brings me to one of the best shows on television Shark Tank. In this series five investors are tasked with weeding out the most promising pitches and using their wealth to back them. The sharks glean insights into how to better position products and services–most importantly how to make busy people care.

Today I pose the question “what qualities can brands exhibit to make influencers care?” Below I look at each shark’s style and the qualities that appeal to them.

Screen Shot 2013-02-19 at 11.32.15 AM
(Shark Tank Cast, Barbara Corcoran not pictured)

Barbara Corcoran

While fellow shark Mr. Wonderful often calls Barbara “grandma” don’t be fooled, there will be no milk and cookies served. Recently at the Fancy Food Show I met two entrepreneurs who secured 50K from Corcoran for 50% of their company–only after she told one of them he looked like the pig featured on the label of his bbq sauce. He could take a joke and he’s grateful he could because there was more to Barbara than the bellicose style. If you have thick skin and have a clever new idea, she might just fall for you too, ugly or not. Note she doesn’t like to invest in things she wouldn’t use herself and she doesn’t like products that come with baggage. If you’ve got charisma she’s more likely to work with you. The scene is 5 mins 48 seconds in to the clip below.

Mark Cuban

You might not know that “Cuban” is a surname shortened from “Chabenisky”–Cuban’s grandparents were Russian Jews who got a name change at Ellis Island. Cuban is the darling of the show. He’s the wealthiest of the investors and the most famous. He rarely speaks first and he’s a straight shooter who is quick to calculate a situation. He often politely backs out of deals by acknowledging the product is out of his focus area. He’s also quick to call b.s on products he feel lack integrity (remember the power band–the “negative ions” products Cuban accused of being a scam?). Did I tell you he owns the Dallas Mavericks? He’s not shy, and Cuban has been fined for at least $1,665,000 for 13 incidents called out by the NBA for being critical about…the NBA. Mark appreciates humility, ingenuity and spirit in entrepreneurs. Exhibit these qualities and he might just choose you.

Robert Herjavec

Maybe it’s the Canadian in Herjavec that makes him seem like the boy next door, or maybe it’s his big blue eyes. Either way he’s usually the one who empathizes with the underdogs. He will step in and try to explain things to the contestants in layman’s terms. From what I can tell he’s the most sensitive of the male sharks and would do very well in a room full of women. If you reach him on an emotional level it is likely he will love you and your product. He was eight years old when his family immigrated to Canada from Croatia hence his appreciation for a strong work ethic. He also appears to have an affinity for conscious capitalism.

Lori Greiner

Greiner is known on the show as Mrs. QVC. She has hundreds of patents and a sharp eye for what will sell to the QVC audience. Greiner has an ability to retain her femininity without being swallowed up by the shark tank. She makes no apologies, stands her ground and knows how to deal with any negative criticism about QVC. On her Facebook Page she posts inspirational status updates and is the only shark who engages directly with her fans. She invests in products and even more importantly, people. While Greiner has a big heart, it’s a heart of gold–and that’s what she’s after. Keep in mind if she makes you an offer and you put it over ice for too long, she might just rescind it. She values creativity, relevance and loyalty.

Kevin O’Leary (AKA Mr. Wonderful)

Mr Wonderful is possibly the most shark-like-shark out of the group. He can be outright mean but will surprise you. Who knew he decided to be an entrepreneur as a teenager when he was bullied by his boss at the local ice cream shop? O’Leary-the second wealthiest shark on the show-is not cuddly, but if he believes in your product (and thinks you can take the heat) you might get lucky. Looking at O’Leary’s record he prefers royalties to equity. If you don’t need a warm fuzzy relationship with this investor he might just help you realize your dream. If he let’s you in perhaps he’ll play you a song on his guitar.

Daymond John

John is a sought after shark due to his marketing genius and world re-known brand Fubu. If the product is retail or appeals to the industry you might get his interest. John personally values work ethic since he started his business with not much money and a wife and one year old at home. He likes products with a strong sales track record out the gate and entrepreneurs who don’t fumble on their numbers. He’ll question your valuation, and isn’t above rolling his eyes. If he rejects you he’ll at least have the decency to do it in a cute and sassy way.

Getting influencers to care about products and services can be more difficult than securing an investment. What can you possibly give an influencer to make them interested?

I’ll answer that question in another post. For now you have some tips around values, personality and style to think about.

The Keys to Blackberry’s Midlife Crisis?

When people get insecure they do brash things. They get tattoos, they buy expensive new outfits and they date arm candy.

So when brands are looking for a positive change, they sometimes choose the wrong arm candy for attention.

This week we saw Research In Motion change its name and court the queen of cool–musician Alicia Keys. Don’t get me wrong, I have a lot if respect for Keys as a musician–she isn’t just another pretty face. However, just like when The Atlantic published a full spread sponsored content on Scientology, a lot of us are scratching our heads.

Screen Shot 2013-02-01 at 12.28.27 PM

Thorsten Heins, CEO of RIM, introduces Alicia Keys as the global creative director of BlackBerry. Yes. Photograph: Mark Lennihan/AP

Would Blackberry have more luck embracing the customers who stand by its product–however uncool they might be? While I believe Keys is a woman if substance, the match just doesn’t add up. Is Blackberry going through a midlife crisis? And anyway, is Keys’` influence enough to help Blackberry move through this awkward phase in its life?

We’ve seen other influencer engagements go terribly wrong. One includes one of my favorite comedians Jerry Seinfeld who couldn’t quite win over hearts when it came to appearing in a commercial with Bill Gates.

Screen Shot 2013-02-01 at 12.30.17 PM

I believe Blackberry’s midlife crisis might be a reminder to own your authenticity. Even if your brand doesn’t rank well on the hipster-meter and people don’t associate your brand with sleek, agile and savvy–that doesn’t mean you don’t have raving fans. Go find and embrace the fans who do LOVE you and engage them.

Note to Blackberry, if you do want to engage an influencer maybe you should try Marnie’s character (Allison Williams) from the huge HBO hit GIRLS who was seen texting from a blackberry in last Sunday’s episode. She might be sitting on the toilet but maybe there’s a niche market here.

Screen Shot 2013-02-01 at 12.22.39 PM

Your Inner Glow: An Interview with Oakland Photographer Nancy Rothstein

There’s no question that representing yourself in a professional way online can be of great benefit. Having a headshot for your website and your social profiles that is clean, bright and flattering can be a real differentiator. Representing the best version of yourself helps send the right message to prospective new clients, recruiters or potential mates.

What I’ve learned is I grew up insecure about my looks. These insecurities have fueled many of the ideas in this blog and turned into a passion for helping other women feel good about themselves. I always say when I heal other women I heal myself, and when I heal myself I heal other women.

Over time I’ve learned to accept myself and embrace the very things that make me different. I’ve also learned that when I feel happy, I look better in photographs. I believe this is true for other women as well.

It has taken me almost three decades to feel mostly comfortable with myself. Today I know the importance of putting my best foot forward. While there are a million ways things that can go wrong with branding, having nice photos is one advantage that’s easy to take care of. We all need to do the best with what we have.

I’ve recently changed my hair color and I’ve never had professional headshots taken. I recently met a photographer at a NAWBO event named Nancy Rothstein. I learned more about her process, saw her incredible portfolio and wanted to work with her.

Nancy is passionate about helping women feel amazing about themselves, and having that glow come through in her photography. I love working with other women small business owners who are also on a journey to help lift up other women. I can’t say enough positive things about the experience I had with her. She was gentle through the whole process, and a true perfectionist. She made me laugh throughout our photo shoot. She is a true master of light and has an uncanny ability to draw that spirit out of you–and make it come through in your headshot. Learn more about Nancy’s philosophy and views on self esteem in our interview below.

Blake Landau: What is a common reaction you find from clients who are getting their head-shots done for the first time?

Nancy Rothstein: Many people come in saying something like:

I don’t photograph well
I’m not photogenic
I hate photos of myself 
I’ve never had a photo of myself that I’ve liked
I’m really uncomfortable in front of the camera

BL:  Is there a difference between men and women with regard to being self-conscious in front of the camera?

NR: I think it depends on the person. I’ve had both genders [clients] who are self-critical and uncomfortable. Both genders have come in with specific things about themselves that they don’t like. I wouldn’t want to generalize but I do think men are more comfortable with themselves. But I think pretty much everyone has challenges seeing themselves.

BL: Do you have any advice for people who feel insecure about their looks or their weight as far as appearing confident in front of the camera?

NR: Well the first part of that answer is at the root of my beliefs—to remember that your beauty is not skin deep. We’re all inherently beautiful—and it’s our human spirit that makes us beautiful. You know that’s true because you experience someone who is “beautiful” by society and media standards, and you know that it would be possible to interact with someone like that and feel that they’re actually ugly in the way they behave or treat other people. Real beauty is inside of us.

If we remember that real beauty comes from our spirit–and tap into that–we’ll naturally be more relaxed and express our beauty in a photograph. Internal beauty comes out through the face and the expression—it doesn’t matter how much they weigh, how many wrinkles they have, how many spots they have, gray hairs, make-up etc. When a person is shining through their eyes and their expression no one looks at that image and says, “oh they need to lose ten pounds.” They look at it and say “wow what a beautiful person.”

Beyond that technique is very important. You have to choose the right photographer. You want to choose a photographer that can bring your inner glow out. Who can help you to be at east in front of the camera, who can see you for who you are and understand what it is you want to express with your image and be able to draw that out.

There are proven techniques in photography that flatter the subject. In a still image you want to do everything possible to make the image flattering whether that’s lighting, camera angle or composition. Bad lighting can make a model look bad. Additionally we all have asymmetry in our faces. The way the photographer poses you and lights you accentuates the asymmetry or balances it. That’s really important in a still image. When we’re animated and interacting with each we don’t notice that. But real life and a still image are very different ways to be perceived.

BL: How do you help people relax when they’re getting their picture taken?

NR: I have a process that starts before the session in my phone consultation. At that time I talk to the client about what they’re trying to express. What aspects of their personality they’re trying to convey with the image. I also give them homework and have them think about things that relate to the qualities they want to portray in their photograph. In the example of a professional person I might have them think about their favorite client, or the feeling they get from being of service to their clients. It could be a feeling of competence of doing their best work. It could be a virtue they’re striving to embody. It could be anything. I don’t ask them to necessarily share it with me but reflect on it prior to the session. During the session I’m very actively coaching them to reflect on these things and to have their inner experience of tapping into those qualities. The ultimate goal is to create an authentic image that feels spontaneous in the context of a contrived photo shoot. That process which is a combination of mediation and method acting helps the subject to experience something authentic that specifically relates to how they want to be perceived during the session rather than looking at a camera and feeling self-conscious.

BL: Why do you love your job?

NR: I love interacting with people and I love creating dynamic images. I’ve been using a camera since I was seven years old. It ‘s a natural way for me to interact with the world. Lately one of my deepest satisfactions with my work is that I create images that remind people of their essential beauty.

All photos in this blog were taken by Nancy Rothstein. Find Nancy on Facebook and Twitter or her website

Influencers Will Not Save You

Have you heard stories about celebrities and how they get to super-stardom? A young attractive girl is walking in the mall and she is….DISCOVERED. She is discovered by the talent scout or industry influencer who takes her under his wing and makes her a superstar. She is picked up for the Mickey Mouse Club, or another late 80s or early 90s TV show, and her career is launched.

I fear we seem to have this attitude when it comes to twitter as well.

Influencers generally build a reputation via talent. They don’t get a fan-base by sitting around hoping to be discovered or asking other people to make them seem good at something they aren’t really good at.

Marketing might be a lot harder in today’s social media world because you can no longer automate it, nor can you buy leads. You need to work hard to make yourself relevant, build relationships and build a community that way. We need to stop worrying so much about influencers.

Focus On the Work:

It is hard to be successful and spend all your time supporting other people. You have to focus on yourself and becoming really good at what you love to do.  In the age of social media now more than ever you need to put out great content, and build followship that way. You will attract other people in time who love what you love, and they will support you. They will show up out of nowhere. You will see over time the way this works.

We need to stop asking for attention from influencers, and just focus on what we’re creating.

Don’t worry about what influencers think. Just keep doing your thing. If you do it enough, and it’s good, you will get attention in time.

And most importantly it’s actually the people around you that will ultimately help you become successful. Look around you. Who do you see?

Choosing between my Ass and my Face: Why I will never become a CEO and why that is okay

This is a guest post written by a law school student under the pen name Vicki P.

There is a popular expression that all women eventually have to choose between their ass and their face.

As I creep dangerously close to my 30s, this has certainly rung true! You can’t have a tiny tuchus without ending up with a bony face and vice versa. But as I was filling out my to-do list today—one that was too long to even fit in my daily planner—I started thinking about how this is applicable to more things than just my body.

My to-do list for the day included about 18 hours worth of work: two articles to review for a University Journal that I edit; a canned food drive; a Junior League meeting; three classes; a report for work; looming deadlines for the two different scholarly articles I am writing (i.e., these 45 page monsters!); meetings; and I can’t forget to send my resume to the gentleman I met yesterday who has a job that I very much want. In addition to work, school, and community service, I want to celebrate with my good friend who got engaged yesterday. I don’t want to miss the swing dance lessons that I’ve been taking with my boyfriend. I want to call my friend who I have not spoken to in over two weeks. I don’t want to miss out on restaurant week. I want to do it all.

Something has to give.

There is a fine line between being well-rounded and stretched too thin. And while you may be able to pull it off for a while, there will come a point where you can no longer have both a great ass and a great face. It’s just not possible.

Of course, that story is a deceased horse that has been sufficiently beaten. And the point of this blog entry is not about the fact that we can’t have it all. That problem really isn’t unique to women although sometimes I think we tend to claim it as our own. The point of this entry is that you have to choose. And you need to know why you are making certain choices and then be happy with them. Of course those choices come with certain societal pressures and often frustrating outcomes.

Priorities

Although it is a constant battle, I made my choice several years ago. After seeing a good friend’s marriage slowly fall apart because both spouses were married to their job, I promised myself that I would always prioritize my relationships over my career. And for the most part, I have remained faithful to that promise. This does not mean I am all play and no work, but that I value the “play” in my life and work pretty hard to make sure it happens. I went swing dancing with my boyfriend last night even though I have deadlines the size of Mount Rushmore resting on my shoulders. Despite having a day full of meetings, I still set aside time to have a cupcake break with a good friend. And last week, even though I was up at 6am for work and then busted my tail non-stop until about 8:00 at night, I set aside time for a movie night with the boyfriend. And all of those decisions mean that I let some aspect of my work suffer over some aspect of a personal relationship.

And of course that choice has consequences. I won’t graduate at the top of my class (although, admittedly, that probably would not have happened regardless of my priorities), I will never be a CEO, and I will be fighting constantly to assert where my priorities lie. Making such choices also has another consequence—I must respect the choices that others make if I want them to respect mine. For example, (and I want to preface this with the fact that my boyfriend really is a great guy and has apologized for hurting my feelings), last week, as I wrote above, I made plans to watch a movie with my boyfriend. I worked really hard during the day to get everything done in time to see him. But then he never showed. He fell asleep and when I called him, he told me he was too tired to come over. Priorities.

Taking It Personal?

But while I was mad at him for standing me up, I do not know if I can necessarily be mad at him for how he has chosen to prioritize his life. That is the thing—we all have to decide what is most important to us and then live with those consequences, both the good and the bad. Being one to lean a little left politically, I often throw around the clichéd “uneven playing field” argument, so the one thing I especially appreciate about time is that everyone has the same amount of it. So when people say they are too busy for something, what they really mean is that it is not a priority. Maybe they want to do something, but ultimately, we all choose how we spend our waking hours.

And going back to the article Blake posted about women as CEOs, I know my choices mean I will never become one. And I am okay with that. But that does not mean that choice does not come with a lot of societal pressure. I have been fortunate to go to one of the top law schools in the country and the best in my state. So when I express to women that what would really make me happy is to marry and have children, they look at me as if I am a fool. Why would I waste my education? All that hard work? All that money wasted! I must be desperate. “Look at your boyfriend, he isn’t making that choice, so why should you?” they ask.

The Happiness Conundrum

And as women, I think we often make that argument. That it isn’t fair that women have the dual responsibility of family and work. I agree that that argument has merits. And I do not have children, so I will not expose my naivety by even beginning to try to address what that choice must feel like. But what I do want to address, and it is something that I think is often ignored, is that men make those choices, too. They, too, have to choose how they prioritize their time. They, too, face social pressures to prioritize certain area over others. We all are working with the same 24 hours.

And that is where I think we need to change the dialogue. I often find myself letting others dictate what should be my priorities. I allow myself to feel guilty about certain decisions I make regarding the allocation of my time. And I imagine I am not alone. And I suppose across different social circles, those pressures shift in one way or another, but the bottom line is that we are letting others tell us what should make us happy. But one of my favorite things about the true feminist movement is that it is all about choice.  You can choose to be a CEO. You can choose to be a stay-at-home mom. You can choose to be a working mom. You can choose to have no children at all, but still make personal relationships a priority. You can choose the life you want to live. Of course, going full circle, you cannot choose, at least not successfully, all of the above. That is where you ultimately have to decide what is most important to you. What will make you happiest?

Choose to be happy.

To Be Right, Or To Be Kind

You can learn a lot about a person by watching the way the individual treats others. The way they treat others is a reflection of how they treat themselves.

The softer, kinder and gentler an individual is with others, the more forgiving and loving they are toward themselves. The more judgmental, critical and angry an individual acts toward others, the more they are that way with themselves.

Whether you are someone’s boss, friend, mentor, coach, neighbor, teacher, waiter, customer, or spouse, everyday you are faced with opportunities for communication.

Do we decide to be right, or do we decide to be kind? While it might be easier to make someone feel wrong, it is more powerful to soften your heart and do the opposite.

The Dalai Lama once said, “If you want others to be happy, practice compassion. If you want to be happy, practice compassion.”

So will you decide to be right, or will you decide to be kind?
image source

Cooking Up Social Good at My New Employer TechSoup Global

The best job I ever had, was the one I wasn’t paid for. It was my role as President of New York Toastmasters.

The universe was pulling me toward non-profit, but I couldn’t see it.

Eventually the universe sent me enough signs (yes I just said that).

Omens directed me toward the world of social good. My aha moment and subsequent discovery was TechSoup Global, a nonprofit founded in 1987 on the belief that technology is a powerful enabler for social change. I will be the Social Media Manager for TechSoup Global–an organization that manages product donations of commercial hardware and software to more than 80,000 non-profit organizations in 23 countries.


Some numbers showing the impact TechSoup global has made

Why Non-Profit Is Hot During A Recession

Here’s the truth.

The world needs more help than it ever did. Additionally there appears to be more grassroots activism unfolding as a result of access of free “connector tools” (we can call this social media) and innovative support systems.

My generation–Millennials–according to researcher Bruce Tulgan–are more “hopeful” than any other generation in history.

What do you have?

A planet in need of extreme fixing. A generation of young people who want to help.

In my opinion it’s just a matter of connecting those who need help with the tools and resources to make it happen. Win Win Win.

Who Runs TechSoup Global?

TechSoup Global is run by three CEOs, Daniel Ben-Horin, Rebecca Masisak, and Marnie Webb. I will be working with Susan Tenby, the Director of Online Communities, TechSoup.org, and Non-profit Commons in Second Life.
I read an article from 2009, where CEO and founder Ben-Horin talked about the importance of looking for opportunity in times of turmoil. While most people wouldn’t assume non-profits would flourish during tough times, history shows us quite the contrary.

After the dot com bust TechSoup had a surge in applicants.

Founder and CEO Ben-Horin said, “There was this increasing feeling that something was missing, that selling toothpaste on the Web was not enough. I see something similar happening today, where giving is a way to validate your role in a world in financial turmoil.” While Ben-Horin said this in 2009, I believe it is very relevant today.

Onward and Upward

I see this as not only an opportunity to help those in need, but an opportunity to put my passion to use. While consulting has been an incredible growth process, I know this is the right move for me at this time.

On Susan Tenby’s team I will be working with Michael DeLong, Susan Chavez and more amazing, incredibly generous people.

Below are a few of the case studies from non-profits in New Zealand who have been supported by TechSoup.

*Thank you to friends, family, clients and former colleagues who have supported me in my own journey. Thank you to Jacob Morgan who has been there for me through thick and thin. I am a very blessed person. I am also a person who is more ready than ever to role up her sleeves and dive in.

**If you will be in New York next week and want to find out more about TechSoup Global I will be at CRM Evolution. Please attend my session on Wednesday, August 10th at 8am where I will be talking about Managing Gen Y alongside Jon Blum, Chief Illuminator for Infinite Green. I will be in Australia Aug. 18-30th and will have access to email. I will be formally starting with TechSoup Global September 1st.

VIP Influencer Communities-Are You Drinking the Kool-Aid?

Syed Balkhi, founder of a beginner’s guide for wordpress WPBeginner, has been drinking Mountain Dew since he was 12 years old.

Eight years later he is still a loyal Mountain Dew drinker and has been recognized as a key influencer by the brand and is known as one of the top 20 mountain dew fans in the world.

Balkhi was one of 50 people selected to vote on new Mountain Dew flavors. Balkhi was sent eight drinks in a wooden box decorated like a custom painting. They also sent him a Flip Mino camera along with Mountain Dew shot glasses. He was given access to a secret Mountain Dew Blog community, where he was asked for his input and feedback on various activities regarding the brand. He regularly gets an assortment of other value ads including coupons from Mountain Dew in the mail.

No wonder Balkhi’s eyes sparkle when he talks about Mountain Dew.  I met Balkhi at Blog World on a helicopter ride sponsored by the vendor InfoLinks. They planned an offline version of the external influencer community. It was the highlight of the event.

More companies are creating smarter, targeted and thoughtful digital marketing efforts. It’s truly the end of an era—one where sloppy inauthentic spam marketing made the cut. Now as marketers we need to treat every customer like we were greeting them in a corner grocery store.

The External Community is the New Focus Group

VIP influencer programs like the Mountain Dew campaign kill two birds with one stone. The dead birds include market research and viral marketing.

These external communities can be likened to an exclusive club—think velvet ropes, bouncers with biceps and bottle service. It’s the Meatpacking district of virtual market research.

These non-Facebook communities are good for the influential customers, the company and the crowd of future purchasers. The brand is no longer engaging influencers on someone else’s platform where data is not owned or controlled by the brand. The exchange happens in a private and secure area.

This VIP room, now cost effective due to its virtual nature, is the company’s golden ticket.

The idea “what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas” should be applied to your influencer community. The influencers, privy to secret information, should sign an NDA (non-disclosure agreement).

As I said I met Mountain Dew evangelist Balkhi at a helicopter ride at Blog World sponsored by InfoLinks. The helicopter ride reflects this change in marketing mind-set.

How much would it cost to fly 20 of your most “influential” customers up in a helicopter? The answer is a lot! Now you can engage them in a private external community and save your helicopter dollars to spend on your Christmas party.

So while most people that I know don’t drink Mountain Dew, I see more of you drinking the “kool-aid” as it relates to targeted marketing campaigns.

Investing in Your External Community or the Future Valuation of Facebook? My Interview with Retail Prophet Doug Stephens

This week I am at Blog World in Las Vegas– in light of the event and the upcoming webinar my company blueKiwi Software will be hosting on social business for retail with speakers Esteban Kolsky, Principal with ThinkJar and customer Laurence Mayer of Corporate Training for Louis Vuitton–I interviewed Doug Stephens, President of Strategy Consultancy Retail Prophet Consulting.

Doug Stephens is thought by many to be one of the world’s only retail industry futurists. He’s worked with some of North America’s best known retailers and brands including Wal-Mart, Home Depot, Hudson’s Bay Company, Disney, Loblaw and Benjamin Moore. Prior to founding Retail Prophet Consulting Doug spent 20 years in retail holding senior international roles, including the leadership of one of New York City’s most iconic retail chains. Doug is the author of Retail Prophet’s Shift 2020 Retail Trends Report and a member of the Retail Wire Brain Trust. He is also founder of the Retail Prophets industry think-tank and a Contributing Blogger to Technorati’s business channel. In addition, Doug sits on the advisory board of the Location-Based Marketing Association. Check out our interview to learn more about external community management, social business and the future of retail!

***
http://ezinearticles.com/members/mem_pics/Doug-Stephens_313244.jpg

Blake Landau : Doug you have told me before it’s a mistake to build communities on Facebook. Why do you think this is the case?

Doug Stephens: In the short-term, I don’t necessarily think it’s a mistake for brands to build communities within Facebook. For many brands, a Facebook page serves as a good introduction to what hosting a community is all about.  And I know given Facebook’s growth that it seems counterintuitive that brands should look elsewhere but in the longer term I do foresee the need for brands to establish communities outside Facebook for few reasons;

Firstly, when brands put money into developing a presence on Facebook, they’re really contributing to building the assets of Facebook – not their own.   When they drive traffic to their page, they’re adding to the richness of Facebook’s database, not their own.  They are simply the curator of something that Facebook ultimately owns.  I think brands will slowly awaken to this and begin to look for ways to better allocate those assets.

Secondly, as branded Facebook pages become increasingly ubiquitous, I think companies will seek to create greater levels of differentiation.  The only way to achieve this will be through developing their own branded communities.   There will be a more exclusive feel to many of these communities, in contrast to the communal feel of Facebook.  They will likely represent consumers who consider themselves a step above merely being a Facebook fan of a given brand.

Lastly, I think building a social community outside Facebook makes a stronger statement about both the brand and the consumers that join it.  It signifies the desire to offer and engage in a somewhat deeper and perhaps more meaningful relationship or dialogue.

The ultimate goal should be to create a branded social experience that has such high perceived value that consumers would literally be willing to pay to belong to the community.  If you can get to that level, you’ve really created something remarkable.  Look at it this way; People pay to get into Disney World for a reason.

Having said all that, I do feel that Facebook can and will continue to serve as one of many access points or paths into these branded communities.  It’s still a great place to initiate Consumer interest in your brand.

BL: What do you think is the future of the retail industry as it relates to purchasing patterns?

DS: We’re at a really interesting point right now in North American retail.  We’ve essentially come to the end of an era – that was sort of sped to its conclusion by the recession.

For about the last 30 years retailers have been able to count on relatively steady and robust demand across a massive and homogenous consumer base – the baby boomer family.  When you add a historic level of credit spending into the equation it was like rocket fuel for retail.

All signs are pointing to the beginning of a very different looking period, where demand is increasingly less predictable, consumer preferences more fleeting and customer segments smaller and more diverse.  There’s no one consumer group that constitutes the bulls eye anymore.

I think we’ll continue to see growth in both the super-luxury and super-discount segments but a widening value gap in the middle. And all consumption will be more thoughtful than we’re accustomed to.

BL: Why do you think social business will be important to the retail community?

DS: For the same reasons social business was important 200 years ago.  Social business isn’t new.  If the village shoe maker wanted to stay in business he needed to understand the needs and preferences of his customers.  He also needed to know first-hand what made them happy.  In turn, his customers would either spread positive or negative word of mouth. None of that has changed it’s only been digitalized.  The mass media era, beginning around the 1920’s was really just a fad – a blip that lasted less than a century.  In every other time in history, businesses succeeded by connecting personally with their customers.  We’re simply returning to that.

BL: In your opinion is it important to have a customer engagement strategy and collaboration strategy on the same platform?

DS: Yes.  You may recall through 1990’s companies everywhere were preaching the benefits of employee empowerment and connecting every employee to the needs of the customer.  Unfortunately, very few companies could actually execute against that rhetoric.

A social business strategy that places internal collaborative systems at the center of the customer community achieve this implicitly. Every employee can then be connected to both the needs of their consumer and also to the internal collaborative process in meeting those needs – there can even be points of cross-over where customers become co-collaborators.  This requires enormous trust on the part of companies in their people.

BL: Are retailers ready to buy social business software platforms?

DS: Like everything else, I see a real spectrum of understanding and comfort in the retail community with respect to social marketing.  Early adopters like Best Buy and Starbucks are already there.  For many others, a branded Facebook page is still a daunting idea.

Statistically anyway, the majority of major brands surveyed indicate that they’ve at least made social marketing a budget item for 2011 but I doubt that a high percentage are far enough along the curve to consider developing their own communities outside facebook.  Like most things however, when it hits the inflection point it will tip quickly.  The goal for all brands will be to own the best social experience in their category and I don’t believe that can be achieved without taking ownership of the platform.

For more on Doug Stephens you can reach him at www.retailprophet.com

The Two Step Process to Brand Building Through Influencer Communities

If Christopher Columbus were a marketer he would still be using Google and Facebook.

Let’s veer from the “West Indies” of social media marketing. Below is a map providing a faster route to a land full of sugar and spice and everything nice.

The Map to Social Biz Marketing

We are all in the experimentation phase of social. As marketers we explore. We set out to sea, land (sometimes in the wrong territory), track mistakes and successes and adjust our map. My map isn’t necessarily sexier than your map–but considers some recent mistakes you might not have heard about.

There’s no question that it’s important to have influencers and brand advocates on your radar.  Let’s face it–it’s good to be in the light of the influencer. But influencers aren’t generally as easy to find as omniscient Oprah–they are currently moving targets.

Finding and engaging influencers, and turning them into advocate, takes blood, sweat and tears. Or at least it used to…

The good news is some people are working very hard to simplify this process. It’s now a refreshingly easy two-step process.

Step 1: Identify Your Influencers.
Step 2:
Bring Them Into A Branded Community.

http://www.amazinghealth.co.uk/DOG-STEP.jpg

1. What is the easiest way to identify your influencers?

Recent college grads are kicking themselves for wasting a $100,000 dollar education “googling” all day. Fortunately for these millennials Google is possibly on its way out-at least for marketers.

What defines an influencer?

In defining an influencer there’s the philosopher‘s answer and there’s the scientist‘s answer.

The philosopher’s answer–>

Influence comes from confidence, vision and timing.

The scientist’s answer–>

If you ask Michael Wu, PhD, Principal Scientist for Lithium, he might tell you something different. In Michael’s blog The 6 Factors of Social Media Influence he talks about two criteria for gauging influence:

a. Credibility: The influencer’s expertise in a specific domain of knowledge.

Please note: There is no such thing as a universal influencer, because no one can possibly be influential in all domains. The best that anyone can hope for is an influencer in a specific domain of knowledge

b. Bandwidth: The influencer’s ability to transmit his expert knowledge through a social media channel.

Please note: Active influencers in one channel may not even be present on another channel. So influencers are not only specific to a domain of knowledge, they are specific to social media channels

Marketing is a different animal today. The way we gauge influence has shifted. As Michael wrote, not only are influencers specific to a domain, but they are also specific to a particular channel. At first glance this seems to make marketer’s jobs even harder.

How do we hit these rapidly moving targets?

The answer is Klout a service that measures overall influence across the web. To measure influence the metric considers:

  • the size of your engaged audience
  • the likelihood that your messages will generate actions (retweets, @messages, likes and comments) on a scale of 1 to 100
  • Network score indicating how influential your engaged audience is

I recently met Klout’s CEO Joe Fernandez. He told me he had the idea for the company when his jaw was shut for a period of three months due to a medical procedure.

Klout counters one of the biggest fallacies about social media–the lie that that brands have lost control. Companies like Klout illustrate the fact that the power is there for the taking. Power can be re-assumed by the brand and its care-takers. 

Step 2: Now that I’ve found my army where do I put them?

Courting influencers can be likened to paying for celebrity endorsements–only difference is courting influencers is much cheaper and less risky. Remember when GM paid Tiger Woods $40 million for a 5-year contract ending in 2009. Well we all know how that turned out.

So let’s make your life easier. Find your influencers and bring them into a private external community.

Stop! I know you are thinking about le Facebook. Facebook is not a long-term strategy. Rather Facebook is a short-term investment where you don’t control the data. You are essentially investing in the future valuation of Facebook.

With this map you are now investing in YOUR OWN platform. You have assumed control over your brand’s communication and messaging. This route leads to sugar and spice and everything nice. You are not in the West Indies-and you know that 100%.

*Carlos Diaz, CEO of blueKiwi Software and Doug Stephens President of Retail Prophet both contributed to  research for this blog.